Why Locals Love Cicis Pizza
Situated on W Walnut St in Rogers, Arkansas, CiCi’s Pizza offers a warm and inviting dining experience that’s perfect for families and pizza lovers alike. Specializing in a diverse range of Italian-inspired dishes, this bustling pizza restaurant and buffet spot masterfully balances quality, variety, and value in every visit.
CiCi’s Buffet is renowned for its all-you-can-eat appeal, featuring an extensive selection of freshly made pizzas anchored by their signature traditional garlic butter crust. Standout favorites include the classic Pepperoni pizza, generously layered with savory pepperoni slices and melted real cheese; the comforting Cheese pizza, with its rich, gooey mozzarella atop a perfect tomato sauce base; and the hearty Beef and Italian-style Sausage pizzas, which add a satisfying, meaty depth to the crust’s crisp yet tender bite.
A true highlight at CiCi’s Pizza is the colossal Piezilla, an epic 64-slice giant that’s tailor-made for celebrations and large gatherings. Loaded with gooey mozzarella and your choice of toppings, it delivers a feast of flavor that’s both indulgent and crowd-pleasing. For those who prefer a-la-carte or takeout, this giant pizza is available for easy pickup, making it ideal for family nights or party catering.
Beyond pizza, the menu tantalizes with an array of flavorful sides that include crispy, tender Garlic Cheese Breadsticks crafted from deep dish dough, warming soups with chicken and cavatappi pasta, and two types of perfectly sauced pasta—one with a zesty marinara and the other with a smooth, creamy Alfredo. Not to be overlooked, the Buffalo Chicken Poppers add a spicy kick, enveloped in fresh pizza dough for a gooey, satisfying bite.
Customers frequently praise CiCi’s for its fresh and hot offerings, with Carly Mercer highlighting the well-stocked pizza and pasta options, along with a refreshing salad bar. Reid Slaughter raves about the “Best cheese bread & desserts” and the accommodating staff that goes above and beyond to prepare something special if it’s not available on the buffet. Meanwhile, Loistine Glass commends the attentive staff for maintaining a clean, welcoming environment and ensuring the buffet remains abundant with favorite pizzas ready to enjoy.
The atmosphere at CiCi’s Pizza reflects the joyful spirit of a classic family restaurant, combining the casual comfort of a buffet with attentive customer service. The fast, friendly staff seamlessly manage the ebb and flow of hungry patrons, creating a lively yet relaxed ambiance where everyone from kids to grandparents can find something delicious and satisfying.
Although some diners like William Pate noted occasional timing gaps on fresh pizza offerings during peak dinner hours, most agree that the overall experience, especially the value and variety, makes CiCi’s a beloved local staple to revisit frequently. Elijah Pearrow’s evolving positive review echoes this sentiment, noting the restaurant’s almost upscale interior and consistently fast, friendly service complemented by delicious salads, pasta, and desserts that round out the meal beautifully.
Whether you’re craving a pizza feast with friends, a casual family night out, or a convenient takeout option that delivers both quality and quantity, CiCi’s Pizza in Rogers stands out as a dependable choice. Its combination of varied menu selections, welcoming atmosphere, and attentive team ensures every visit leaves you feeling satisfied and eager for the next slice.
See the Space & Food
What Makes This Place Friendly
- No-contact delivery
- Delivery
- Takeaway
- Dine-in
- Lunch
- Dinner
- Solo dining
- Wheelchair-accessible car park
- Wheelchair-accessible entrance
- Wheelchair-accessible seating
- Wheelchair-accessible toilet
- All you can eat
- Comfort food
- Quick bite
- Salad bar
- Lunch
- Dinner
- Catering
- Counter service
- Dessert
- Seating
- Toilet
- Wi-Fi
- Wi-Fi
- Casual
- Family friendly
- Groups
- Tourists
- University students
- Accepts reservations
- Credit cards
- Debit cards
- NFC mobile payments
- Credit cards
- Good for kids
- Good for kids birthday
- High chairs
- Kids' menu
- Free of charge street parking
- Free parking lot
- On-site parking
- Parking
Real Reviews from the Community
- Mar 22, 2026
Food was good for an all you can pizza place. Plenty of fresh pizza n pasta. Hot an d ready. Sslad bar looked good too.
- Mar 17, 2026
Best cheese bread & deserts! Great value!! If you don’t see something you like on the buffet, they’ll hook it up for you.
- Feb 1, 2026
As I was getting my food from the buffet, the staff was quickly cleaning spills that had been made, keeping the place well kept. The staff was making sure they’re was always a pizza out, all the pizza I wanted was there and if not the staff was happy to make it. Their appearance was very nice and is a good representation to CiCi’s. I would let my friends and family know that this CiCi’s is awesome! My daughter even wants me to ask about a birthday party there! The manager made sure that we were well taken care of, and if any issues came about, to go to her.
- Jan 29, 2026
The food was alright a little disappointed. because I went during dinner time and they really didn't have any new pizza out that was fresh. And didn't really have any salad in the salad bar. But it got better pizza after 10 minutes later after being their. I would go back cause I like pizza buffet.
- Jan 13, 2026
OLD I hope I can change this review in the future... UPDATE These are some of my favorite reviews to make Cici's fan all my life... This place is really nice, almost fancy interior. Service fast, staff is very friendly and helpful. For all you can eat buffet- it's a pretty good price. The salad is salad, the pasta is good, and the desserts are good. I've always loved how if they don't have a pizza you like you can order whatever you want free. The pizza quality has improved! My previous review I explained how the quality and taste of the pizza wasn’t the greatest and now I am pleased to say it’s much better! The buffet is worth it if you just eat the cheese sticks! They are amazing! I love it when a pizza comes together! (I mean plan)
- Dec 19, 2025
My family and I had an incredible experience at CiCi’s Pizza thanks to Antonette! From the moment we walked in, she went above and beyond to make us feel welcome. She took the time to suggest some great pizza combinations we hadn’t tried before, and every one of them was spot on! What really stood out was when she made a custom dessert pizza just for our family — and it was amazing! It’s rare these days to find someone who truly cares about their customers, but Antonette clearly takes pride in what she does. Her kindness, attention to detail, and genuine hospitality made this CiCi’s experience better than any other we’ve had. We live in Fayetteville, but after this visit, we’ll gladly make the drive to Rogers every week just to come back and see her! If you’re looking for great food and even better service, go see Antonette at CiCi’s in Rogers — she sets the standard for customer service!
- Dec 3, 2025
This Cicis is SO AMAZING!! The environment felt so positive and family friendly!! I came here with my children and they were very happy to see a arcade area! The whole restaurant was VERY spotless!! If there was a dirty table, the staff would instantly clean it so families could enjoy their food without any mess. Even while I was eating, the staff was gladly asking if they could take my plates and trash I was done with so I wouldn't have to!! And the manager was so helpful!! She had made sure I was doing okay and needed anything, and even gave my little girls coloring pages to keep them entertained!! This Cicis felt great and very positive and I would for sure come back here again when I get the chance!!
- Nov 27, 2025
I had a unbelievably amazing time here. Every person I ran into had a great attitude and very willing to help. For example, I asked this nice young lady in the back for buffalo sauce, and she gave it to me quick and happily! And shoutout to Ms. Antoinette, her bright personality and spirit towards me and my two girls was amazing. It was one of my girls birthday and she went above and beyond to make it special, giving her stickers and coloring sheets! My youngest said she wanted to come back just to see to see Ms. Antoinette! The arcade is a nice touch as well, a good way to drain the kids The area around the place was very nice and well kept, especially for it being very busy for a while. The food was amazing and the staff was legendary!
